Skip to content

Lawgivers, assemblies, lotteries, leagues

Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues

800 BCE – 146 BCE

Early morning in the Athenian Agora, below the rock of the Acropolis. In front of a small colonnaded hall, the Royal Stoa, stand tall wooden boards painted with Solon's laws; citizens of every class crowd round to read them while Solon, robed, points to the text. Olive trees and the sea lie beyond. Toggle to the tyranny: armed club-bearers hold the Acropolis for Peisistratus.

Archaic Athens: Solon's laws on wooden boards

800 BCE – 508 BCE

Archaic poleis and lawgivers

Hundreds of small city-states, most run by landowning aristocrats through yearly magistrates and councils. From about 650 BCE some of them began to write their laws on stone and wood for everyone to see. Three cases show three different answers to the question of who rules.

The Greeks wrote for about a century before anyone wrote a law: the earliest inscriptions, from about 750 to 650 BCE, are all private. Legal inscriptions appear from about 650, from all over Greece, with the greatest concentration on Crete and especially at Gortyn. 2 Consensus Excavation Texts

Most archaic laws do not say who enacted them. Where they do, the community stands behind them, either directly (the oldest law from Dreros opens 'the polis has decided') or through a lawgiver it appointed, like Draco and Solon at Athens. 2 Consensus Texts

A law from Chios, inscribed around 575 BCE, sets up a 'people's council' (boulē dēmosiē) of fifty men from each tribe, with power to inflict penalties and to hear the month's lawsuits. 2 Consensus Texts Excavation

Sara Forsdyke argues that archaic politics often meant expulsion: in Athens and elsewhere, aristocrats seized power by driving their rivals into exile, a violent pattern that elite self-regulation checked only for a while. 4 Debated Texts

Athens621 BCE – 508 BCE

Athens moved from rule by noble archons to written laws, a property-graded citizenship, a tyranny, and finally the reforms of Cleisthenes. Almost everything known comes from texts written two or three centuries later.

Terms: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues: Archaic poleis and lawgivers, Athens

  • thesmos the archaic word for a law: Draco used it for his homicide law, Solon for his own laws 2
  • archōn 'ruler': one of the nine yearly magistrates, at first chosen by birth and wealth 1
A relief map of the Mediterranean and Black Sea seen from above at an angle: pale land on a blue sea, with the land Cliopatria assigns to the Greek city-states raised as terracotta blocks. Step through 750, 650 and 545 BCE to watch the block spread from the Aegean to colonies in Italy, Sicily, North Africa and around the Black Sea. Cliopatria draws the city-states as one group: it does not map Athens on its own. Territories from Cliopatria (CC BY 4.0), coastline from Natural Earth.

The Greek city-states spread across the Mediterranean (Cliopatria)

Territory: Cliopatria (CC BY 4.0), simplified. Height fixed: population not coded in Seshat.

According to the Athenian Constitution, the top offices first went 'by birth and wealth' and were held for life, then for ten years, then for a single year. The Council of the Areopagus, made up of former archons who sat for life, ran most affairs of state and punished offenders without appeal. 1 Debated Texts

Tradition dates Athens's first written laws to Draco in 621/0 BCE. His homicide law is the best attested: Solon kept it, and the Athenians re-inscribed it on stone in 409/8, the copy from which scholars reconstruct it. 2,1 Consensus Texts Excavation

Asked to settle a crisis in 594 BCE, Solon banned loans secured on the borrower's person and cancelled debts, the 'Shaking-off of Burdens'. In his own poem he says he freed men who had been sold into slavery. 1,2 Consensus Texts

Solon graded citizens by the yearly produce of their land into four classes: Five-hundred-measure men, Horsemen, Teamsters and Labourers. The top offices went to the first three; Labourers could sit only in the Assembly and the law-courts. 1 Consensus Texts

The Athenian Constitution says Solon had the nine archons drawn by lot from candidates each tribe had first voted onto a short list. Written some 250 years later, this is the earliest claim of lot in Athens and is not confirmed by any contemporary text. 1 Debated Texts

Solon's laws were written on wooden boards set up in the Royal Stoa, and every citizen swore to keep them. Solon himself wrote that he drafted laws 'for the lowly and the well-to-do alike', giving straight justice to each. 1,2 Consensus Texts

Peisistratus persuaded the Assembly to give him a bodyguard of club-bearers and used it to seize the Acropolis. He ruled, says the Athenian Constitution, 'more constitutionally than tyrannically', until rival factions expelled him; one of them later brought him back. 1 Consensus Texts

Cliopatria does not map Athens on its own: it draws the Greek city-states as a single block, which grows with colonisation from about 58,000 km² in 800–751 BCE to about 189,000 km² in 550–541. 5 Consensus Texts

How power worked Elected magistrates · Mixed · Written law

How power worked

Who rules
Elected magistrates Debated
How chosen
Mixed Debated
Limits on power
Written law Consensus
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Law Debated
Who has a say
Property owners Debated

Sparta

Two hereditary kings, a council of elders and an assembly of Spartan men who could accept or reject what was put to them but not amend it. The account rests on Herodotus and on Plutarch, writing centuries later.

Terms: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues: Archaic poleis and lawgivers, Sparta

  • rhetra an ordinance; the 'Great Rhetra' was the oracle said to found Sparta's government 3
  • gerontesγέροντες the elders: 28 men over sixty who sat with the two kings 6,3
An open meadow by a river under high mountains, with no hall and no seats, as Plutarch says Lycurgus wanted. The twenty-eight elders sit in an arc on the grass with the two kings standing among them; facing them, a crowd of Spartan men in red cloaks listens. They may accept or reject the motion the kings and elders lay before them, but not change it. A plank bridge crosses the river beside them.

Sparta: the assembly between the bridge and the river

Plutarch quotes the 'Great Rhetra', an oracle from Delphi: divide the people into tribes and obai, set up a council of thirty including the two kings, and assemble the people from time to time between the Babyca and the Cnacion, where 'the people must have the deciding voice and the power'. They met in the open, with no hall. 3,2 Debated Texts

No one in the assembly could make a motion: the people accepted or rejected what the kings and elders laid before them. When the people began to amend motions, Plutarch says, kings Polydorus and Theopompus added a rider letting the elders and kings dissolve the meeting. 3 Debated Texts

Herodotus lists the privileges of Sparta's two kings: two priesthoods, the right to make war on any land they chose, a guard of a hundred picked men, double portions at public meals, and seats with the twenty-eight elders in council. 7 Consensus Texts

The council had twenty-eight elders, men over sixty, so that with the two kings it numbered thirty. Plutarch, following Plato, calls it the ballast that kept Sparta from veering towards tyranny or towards democracy. 3 Consensus Texts

Plutarch says the ephors were added about 130 years after Lycurgus, under King Theopompus, as a curb on the oligarchic element. The date depends on a Lycurgus who cannot himself be dated. 3,2 Debated Texts

Unlike Crete or Athens, Sparta kept its basic laws unwritten: Plutarch says one rhetra forbade writing them down, leaving education to do the work of the lawgiver. 3 Debated Texts

Plutarch credits Lycurgus with dividing the land into 9,000 equal lots for Spartans and 30,000 for the free provincials, though he reports other figures too. Stephen Hodkinson challenges this egalitarian image: property and wealth, he argues, mattered throughout Spartan history. 3,8 Debated Texts

How power worked Council of elders or heads · Mixed · Council

How power worked

Who rules
Council of elders or heads Debated
How chosen
Mixed Debated
Limits on power
Council Consensus
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Divine mandate Debated
Who has a say
Male citizens Debated

Crete710 BCE – 508 BCE

Crete had dozens of independent cities governed by yearly officials called kosmoi. Its stone laws are the oldest in Greece. Seshat codes Archaic Crete from 710 BCE.

Terms: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues: Archaic poleis and lawgivers, Crete

  • kosmos the highest official in most Cretan cities; some cities had one, others a board 2
A saddle between two hilltops on Crete, with the small temple of Apollo Delphinios at the edge of the town's open gathering place. Long stone blocks in the temple's east wall carry the town's laws, among them the oldest surviving Greek law: no man may be kosmos twice within ten years. Townsmen stand reading it; the kosmos and the officials who swore to the law wait beside the temple.

Dreros: the oldest Greek law on a temple wall

The oldest surviving Greek law, from Dreros, reads: 'The polis has decided: when someone has been kosmos, within ten years the same person is not to be kosmos again.' A man who breaks this owes double fines for any judgment he gives, loses his rights for life, and everything he does as kosmos is void. 2 Consensus Texts Excavation

French excavators found eight archaic laws in 1936 in a cistern beside Dreros's temple of Apollo Delphinios. They had been carved on blocks of the temple's east wall, which bordered the town's main gathering place, so the laws stood at the heart of the community under the god's eye. 2 Consensus Excavation

The law ends with the officials who swear to it: 'the kosmos and the damioi and the twenty of the polis'. Even the oldest Greek law shows several bodies sharing authority, not one ruler. 2 Consensus Texts

The mason cut vertical lines between words, which most early Greek inscriptions lack. Gagarin argues that this was meant to help readers with only basic reading skills, so the laws were aimed at many people, not a small elite. 2 Debated Excavation Texts

At Gortyn, the earliest laws were inscribed on the walls of the temple of Apollo Pythion, which people visited often; like those at Dreros, they set the god's protection behind the law. 2 Consensus Excavation Texts

Seshat codes Archaic Crete as a 'quasi-polity' with no capital: many small cities, not one state. It records a formal legal code, courts and judges as present, professional lawyers as absent, and no coinage of its own yet. Seshat Consensus Texts

Seshat codes hereditary elite status in Archaic Crete as 'inferred absent'. That sits awkwardly with Aristotle, who wrote later that Cretan cities chose their kosmoi only from certain clans. 9 Seshat Debated Texts

How power worked Elected magistrates · Written law · City-state · 2 unknown

How power worked

Who rules
Elected magistrates Consensus
How chosen
Unknown
Why?

No archaic text says who chose the kosmos or how. Aristotle's statement that kosmoi came from certain clans is about three centuries later (Classical Crete case).

Limits on power
Written law Consensus
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Law Consensus
Who has a say
Unknown
Why?

The Dreros law names 'the polis' as the body that decided, but no archaic Cretan text says who could take part in its decisions.

508 BCE – 338 BCE

Democracy and its rivals

After Cleisthenes, Athens became a democracy run by an assembly of male citizens, a council and juries filled by lot. Sparta kept its kings, elders and ephors; other cities, from Sicily to the Aegean, had democracies of their own; the cities of Crete kept rule by clans and magistrates. The phase ends with Macedon's victory at Chaeronea in 338 BCE.

Thucydides has Pericles define the word: Athens's administration 'favors the many instead of the few; this is why it is called a democracy'. 10 Consensus Texts

Josiah Ober argues that Classical Greece was unusually prosperous, densely populated and urban, and that this was no miracle but the result of political breakthroughs and economic growth in citizen-centred city-states. 11 Debated Texts

Philip and Alexander of Macedon defeated the Greek cities at Chaeronea in 338 BCE, a victory Ober attributes to the Macedonians' use of Greek innovations. 11,12 Consensus Texts

Athens

The best-documented democracy of the ancient world: male citizens voted in the Assembly, served on a council and in huge juries picked by lot, and could exile a leading politician by writing his name on a sherd.

Terms: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues: Democracy and its rivals, Athens

  • dēmokratiaδημοκρατία 'rule of the people': the name Thucydides' Pericles gives Athens's government 13
  • boulēβουλή the Council of 500, chosen by lot, fifty from each tribe 14
  • klērōtēriaκληρωτήρια allotment machines: stone slabs slotted for jurors' tickets, two for each tribe 14,15
  • pinakiaπινάκια jurors' tickets, with name, father's name and deme 14
  • kanonidesκανονίδες the columns of slots on an allotment machine, five on each 14
The Pnyx hillside in the early morning, seen from behind the speaker's platform: thousands of citizens sit on the terraced slope held up by a curved stone wall, facing the rock-cut bema where a speaker stands. Across the valley the Acropolis rises with its temples. Toggle to the vote: hands go up across the slope, the show of hands by which generals were elected. At the foot of the hill, slaves sweep latecomers in from the Agora with a rope wet with red paint.

The Athenian Assembly on the Pnyx

Cleisthenes replaced the four old tribes with ten new ones 'wishing to mix them up'. He split Attica into thirty districts, ten each in the city, the coast and the inland, and gave each tribe one of each by lot, so that every tribe drew men from all over Attica. 1 Consensus Texts

The Assembly met on the Pnyx hill, four times in each presidency of the Council, under a written agenda. One meeting voted to confirm the officials in office and dealt with food supply and defence; generals and other military officers were elected there by show of hands. 1,15 Consensus Texts Excavation

Meetings began at dawn. Slaves swept reluctant citizens up from the Agora with a rope wet with red paint: anyone caught lingering had marked clothes and could be fined. 15 Consensus Texts

The Council of 500, fifty from each tribe chosen by lot, prepared the Assembly's business and met every day except holidays. Each tribe's fifty served in turn as the presidency for about a tenth of the year, dining at public expense in the round Tholos. 1,15 Consensus Texts Excavation

The presidents' chairman was chosen by lot for one day and one night and could never serve again. For that day he held the keys of the treasuries and archives and the state seal. 1 Consensus Texts

By the fourth century almost every routine office was filled by lot, for one year. Only military officers and a few financial posts were elected by show of hands. No civilian office could be held twice, except that a man could sit on the Council twice. 1,15 Consensus Texts

Jurors were allotted with stone machines. Each tribe had two, each with five columns of slots, one column for each jury section. Tickets were slotted in, and as many balls as there were tickets in the shortest column went down a tube, white for the jurors needed and black for the rest. Each white ball made a whole row of five into jurors for the day. 1,14,15 Consensus Texts Excavation

Any citizen over thirty not in debt to the treasury could serve as a juror. The Athenian Constitution counts six thousand jurors in the fifth century; juries ran from two hundred men upwards, and up to ten courts could sit at once. 1,15 Consensus Texts

Pericles introduced pay for jurors. Pay for attending the Assembly came only after the democracy was restored in 403/2 BCE, rising from one obol to three. For its own day the Athenian Constitution lists a drachma for an ordinary Assembly meeting, a drachma and a half for the main one, half a drachma for jurors and five obols for councillors. 1,2 Consensus Texts

Cleisthenes's law on ostracism was first used against Hipparchus son of Charmus, a relative of the tyrant Peisistratus. Each year the Assembly voted on whether to hold one. On the day, citizens scratched a name on a sherd; if at least 6,000 sherds were cast, the man named most often left Athens for ten years but kept his property. 1,16,15 Consensus Texts

Many sherds survive. Big deposits from the early fifth century were dumped to fill potholes in a road leaving the Agora, and they name most of Athens's leading men: Aristeides, ostracised in 483/2 BCE, Themistocles, Cimon, even Pericles, who was never exiled. One adds 'Out with him!'. 15 Consensus Excavation

Forsdyke argues that ostracism was mostly symbolic: a remarkably mild form of exile, rarely used, that stood for the people's power over who stayed in the city. 4 Debated Texts

On a proposal by Pericles, Athens restricted citizenship to sons of two citizen parents, 'owing to the large number of the citizens'. Sons were registered in their deme at eighteen after a vote on their age and free birth. 1 Consensus Texts

The Athenian Constitution says that the tribute of the allies and the taxes fed more than twenty thousand men: six thousand jurors, five hundred councillors, archers, cavalry, dock guards and some 1,400 officials at home and abroad. 1 Debated Texts

After the restoration of democracy in 403/2 BCE, new laws went through a board of law-makers (nomothetai) and the Council, and were written up in public 'for anyone who wishes to see'. 2 Consensus Texts

How power worked Citizen assembly · Lot (sortition) · Independent courts

How power worked

Who rules
Citizen assembly Consensus
How chosen
Lot (sortition) Consensus
Limits on power
Independent courts Consensus
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Popular sovereignty Debated
Who has a say
Male citizens Consensus

Allot a jury with the kleroterion

Model, not evidence

Each tribe's jurors belonged to ten sections, alpha to kappa. A ticket from each man was slotted down his section's column on one of the tribe's two machines, five columns each; as many balls as there were tickets in a machine's shortest column went into its tube, white for the jurors needed and black for the rest. A white ball made the whole row of five into jurors for the day. 1,15

Tickets filed in each section

40 jurors drawn: 4 from every section.

Machine 1: sections Α Β Γ Δ Ε
BallΑΒΓΔΕ
Black homehomehomehomehome
Black homehomehomehomehome
Black homehomehomehomehome
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
Black homehomehomehomehome
Black homehomehomehomehome
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
Black homehomehomehomehome
– outoutoutout
– outoutout
– outout
– outout
– out
Machine 2: sections Ζ Η Θ Ι Κ
BallΖΗΘΙΚ
Black homehomehomehomehome
Black homehomehomehomehome
Black homehomehomehomehome
Black homehomehomehomehome
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
Black homehomehomehomehome
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
White jurorjurorjurorjurorjuror
Black homehomehomehomehome
– outoutoutout
– outoutout
– outout
– out
– out
– out

Neither source says how a tribe's white balls were split between its two machines; the simulator splits them equally, so the quota must be a multiple of ten and every section supplies the same number of jurors.

Count an ostracism

Model, not evidence

The archons first counted all the sherds: with fewer than 6,000 the vote was void. Otherwise the man named on the most sherds went into exile for 10 years. The names below appear on sherds found in the Agora; the numbers are yours to change, since the real tallies do not survive. 16,15

Sherds naming each man

5,900 sherds: fewer than 6,000, so the ostracism is void.

Who could vote, in Athens and Sparta

Data: ancient sources, as cited

Who belonged to the body that voted. A bar appears only where a source gives a number; the rest have none that can be trusted.

Athens

  • Men of two citizen parents, registered at 18 voted No count of all citizens in the sources read; the Athenian Constitution counts 6,000 jurors (men over 30) in the fifth century. 1
  • Women of citizen families no vote no reliable estimate No reliable estimate. 1
  • Resident foreigners (metics) no vote no reliable estimate No reliable estimate. 1
  • Enslaved people no vote no reliable estimate No reliable estimate. 1

Sparta

  • Spartiates who paid into a common mess voted Aristotle: 'not even a thousand' in his day, in a land able to support 30,000 hoplites; tradition said there had once been 10,000. 9
  • Spartan women no vote no reliable estimate No reliable estimate. 9
  • Free provincials (perioeci) no vote no reliable estimate No reliable estimate. 3
  • Helots (serfs) no vote no reliable estimate No reliable estimate. 9
The west side of the Athenian Agora in the fourth century BCE. A square council house, where the Council of 500 chosen by lot met every day, stands beside the round Tholos, where the fifty councillors of the presiding tribe dined at public expense and their chairman for the day kept the keys and the state seal. Colonnaded stoas frame the square; statues of the ten tribal heroes stand on a long base where notices were posted, and citizens cross the open square.

The Agora: Council House and Tholos

Close up on one tribe's two stone allotment machines in the morning before the courts sit. Each slab has five columns of slots, one for each jury section, filled with jurors' bronze tickets. Beside each machine lie the balls in the order they came out of its tube. Rows level with a white ball glow gold: those men serve today. Rows with a black ball go home, and tickets below the shortest column, greyed out, were never in the draw. The presiding archon faces the waiting citizens. The three draws are runs of the page's allotment model on the same queue (40 jurors from 124 tickets): each section always supplies four jurors.

Allotting jurors with the kleroterion

Part of the Agora fenced off with railings for an ostracism, with entrances for the tribes. Citizens file in, each carrying a potsherd scratched with the name of the man he would send away; officials at the entrances collect the sherds and the archons count them. If fewer than 6,000 are cast the vote is void; otherwise the man named most often must leave Athens for ten years. Toggle to the count: the sherds lie heaped, sorted by name, before being shovelled out to fill potholes in the road.

An ostracism in the Agora

Sparta

Classical Sparta's men decided by shouting. Five ephors elected from all citizens held vast powers beside the two kings and the elders, while the number of full citizens shrank.

Terms: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues: Democracy and its rivals, Sparta

  • ephoroiἔφοροι the ephors: five overseers elected yearly from all Spartiates 6
  • phiditiaφιδίτια the common messes every Spartan citizen had to pay into 6
  • boēβοῇ 'by shout': Thucydides' word for how the Spartan assembly decided, 'not by ballot' 13
Sparta under the mountains, an unwalled town of villages. On the left, a company of about fifteen men eats at a common mess around a fire, each having paid in his monthly barley, wine, cheese and figs; a man who could not pay lost his citizenship. On the right, the assembly of Spartan men answers the presiding ephor by shouting. Toggle to the vote on war with Athens, when the ephor claimed he could not tell which shout was louder and made the men walk to two sides.

Sparta: the common mess and the assembly

The Spartan assembly decided 'by acclamation not by voting'. When it debated war with Athens, the presiding ephor said he could not tell which shout was louder and made the men walk to two sides of the meeting place; most held that Athens had broken the treaty. 10 Consensus Texts

Elders were elected for life by shouting. Candidates crossed the assembly one by one in an order set by lot, while judges shut in a nearby room, unable to see, wrote down how loud each shout was. Aristotle called the method 'childish'. 3,9 Consensus Texts

Five ephors, chosen each year from the whole citizen body, controlled Sparta's most important affairs, judged major lawsuits and held other officials to account. Aristotle thought the office 'equal to a tyranny' and complained that poor ephors were easily bribed. 9 Consensus Texts

Every citizen ate in a common mess of about fifteen men and paid in a monthly share of barley, wine, cheese and figs. Aristotle notes the catch: a man who could not pay lost his citizenship. 3,9 Consensus Texts

Aristotle says land had fallen into few hands, nearly two-fifths of it owned by women, and that a country able to support 1,500 cavalry and 30,000 hoplites had fewer than a thousand citizens. Tradition held that Spartiates had once numbered ten thousand. 9 Consensus Texts

Hodkinson argues that Sparta's success rested on a compromise between rich and poor citizens, with differences of wealth masked by a uniform way of life and shared resources. Growing inequality turned it into a plutocracy and brought down Spartan power. 8 Debated Texts

Cliopatria maps Sparta through its alliance, the Peloponnesian League: about 19,700 km² in 450–405 BCE and 22,500 km² in 404–384, shrinking to about 9,000 km² by 366–351. 5 Consensus Texts

How power worked Council of elders or heads · Acclamation · Council

How power worked

Who rules
Council of elders or heads Debated
How chosen
Acclamation Consensus
Limits on power
Council Consensus
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Law Debated
Who has a say
Male citizens Consensus

Democracies beyond Athens480 BCE – 338 BCE

Athens was not alone. Democracies governed cities across the Greek world, though their evidence is scattered: a few lines in a historian, an inscription, a building.

The harbour city of Syracuse in Sicily, a democracy with ships and horses, as Thucydides describes it. In the open square citizens lay olive leaves, each written with the name of the man they think most able to make himself tyrant, on a growing pile; the man with most leaves must leave for five years. Warships ride at anchor in the harbour behind, and horsemen wait at the edge of the square.

Syracuse: exile by olive leaf

Eric Robinson identifies democracies in Classical-period (480–323 BCE) city-states on the Greek mainland, in western and north-western Greece and Cyrene, and in eastern Greece, and sets out to explain why democracy spread so widely in this period. 19 Consensus Texts

The evidence outside Athens is scattered: passages in ancient authors, inscriptions and archaeology. That is why non-Athenian democracy has had only fleeting attention from historians. 19 Consensus Texts Excavation

Thucydides explains Athens's disaster in Sicily partly by this: Syracuse and its neighbours were the only cities Athens had fought that were 'under democracies like themselves', large, with ships and horses, and could not be split by promises of a change of government. 10 Consensus Texts

After attempts at tyranny, Syracuse copied Athenian ostracism as 'petalism': citizens wrote a name on an olive leaf, and the man with most leaves went into exile for five years. Diodorus says it was soon repealed because the ablest men withdrew from public life for fear of it. 20 Debated Texts

Several Greek cities passed laws rewarding whoever killed a would-be tyrant, among them Eretria and Ilion. David Teegarden argues that these laws worked by making it safe to follow the first man who struck, so that would-be plotters knew they would be overwhelmed. 21 Debated Texts

Polybius says the Achaeans of the northern Peloponnese, once ruled by kings, changed to a democracy and tried to keep their league of twelve cities democratic until the time of Philip and Alexander. 22 Debated Texts

How power worked Citizen assembly · Written law · City-state · 2 unknown

How power worked

Who rules
Citizen assembly Debated
How chosen
Unknown
Why?

How officials were chosen varied from city to city and is rarely recorded; the page does not assume Athens's lot applied elsewhere.

Limits on power
Written law Debated
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Popular sovereignty Debated
Who has a say
Unknown
Why?

No citizen lists survive for these cities, so who counted as a citizen, and how many took part, cannot be said.

Crete

Fifth-century Gortyn inscribed the longest law in Greek, while Aristotle saw the Cretan cities as run by clans. Seshat codes Classical Crete from 500 to 323 BCE.

Terms: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues: Democracy and its rivals, Crete

  • kosmoiκόσμοι the ten chief magistrates of a Cretan city 6
  • andreiaἀνδρεῖα 'men's houses': the Cretan common messes, paid for from public land 6
Gortyn's Great Code of the fifth century BCE, shown here as a row of inscribed stone panels, one per column of text: eleven and a half columns, 621 lines, mostly family and property law. A few citizens read it. In front of the wall the ten kosmoi, the city's chief magistrates, stand in a line; according to Aristotle they came only from certain clans. Behind them, men eat together in an andreion, the common mess paid for from public land.

Gortyn: the Great Code

Gortyn's Great Code, probably from the middle of the fifth century BCE, fills eleven and a half columns: 621 lines and more than 3,000 words, mostly family and property law; Gagarin says its scale 'puts it in a class of its own'. 2 Consensus Excavation Texts

Gortyn's laws refer to one another with phrases like 'as is written'. Gagarin argues this gave the sense of a single, connected body of written law, which may have inspired the Great Code. 2 Debated Texts

Aristotle describes ten kosmoi in each city, like Sparta's ephors but chosen 'not from all the citizens but from certain clans'. Former kosmoi sat for life on the council of elders, answerable to no one, and the assembly of all citizens could only confirm what elders and kosmoi had decided. 9 Consensus Texts

Aristotle adds that kosmoi were often thrown out by conspiracies of colleagues or citizens, and that powerful men suspended the office to escape punishment. Crete, he concludes, was 'not actually a republic but rather a dynasty'. 9 Debated Texts

Cretan messes were paid for out of the crops and herds of public land and the tribute of the serfs, so that all citizens, women and children included, were fed from common funds. Aristotle thought this better than Sparta's, where poor men who could not pay lost their citizenship. 9 Consensus Texts

On Crete, as in Sparta, serfs worked the land; but Aristotle observes that Crete's serfs stayed quiet while Sparta's helots often revolted, and he puts this down to the island's distance from foreign wars. 9 Consensus Texts

Seshat gives Classical Crete a territory of 210–240 km², a population of 5,000–30,000 and a largest settlement of about 4,000 people, and now records coins minted on the island, which it codes as absent in the Archaic period. Seshat Consensus Texts

How power worked Elected magistrates · Election · Written law

How power worked

Who rules
Elected magistrates Consensus
How chosen
Election Debated
Limits on power
Written law Debated
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Law Debated
Who has a say
A narrow elite Debated

338 BCE – 146 BCE

Leagues under the kings

After Chaeronea the Macedonian kings dominated Greece, and the cities answered by banding together: federal leagues such as the Achaean and Aetolian elected generals and met in common assemblies. The phase ends in 146 BCE, when the Achaean League was dissolved.

After Chaeronea, Philip summoned a congress of the Greek cities to Corinth. According to Diodorus, the Greeks elected him general plenipotentiary for a war against Persia, and he fixed how many soldiers each city had to send. 12 Consensus Texts

In 337/6 BCE, fearing that ambitious men would court the Macedonian king, Athens passed a law declaring that whoever killed a man trying to set up a tyranny or overthrow the democracy 'shall be blameless'. Its stele carries a relief of Democracy crowning the People. 15,21 Consensus Texts Excavation

By Alexander's time, nearly half of the mainland Greek city-states had given up part of their independence to join larger states called koina, the so-called Greek federal states. Emily Mackil argues that shared cults and long economic ties made this possible. 24 Debated Texts

Macedon338 BCE – 168 BCE

A hereditary kingdom on the northern edge of the Greek world, which under Philip II and Alexander conquered first Greece and then the Persian Empire. Seshat-db codes the Macedonian Empire; it lists the Antigonid kings who followed but codes nothing for them yet.

A plain below snow-capped mountains in Macedon. The king stands on a low platform before his army, called together in assembly as Diodorus says Philip did when he took the throne. In front of him the phalanx, the close-order infantry Philip organised, stands in deep ranks with long spears raised; cavalry wait on the flank and the royal palace stands on the rise behind. Whether such assemblies decided anything is not known.

Macedon: the king addresses his army

Diodorus says Philip, son of Amyntas, took the throne in a crisis, called the Macedonians to a series of assemblies, drilled his men constantly and was the first to organise the Macedonian phalanx. 25 Consensus Texts

Seshat-db's estimates show how fast Macedon grew: about 10,000 km² in 359 BCE, 125,000 km² in 336, 2.5 million km² in 330 and 5.2 million km² in 320, with a population estimate rising from about a million (359–336 BCE) to about 20 million (321). Seshat DB Consensus Texts

In a speech Arrian gives the historian Callisthenes, protesting at Alexander's demand for prostration, the Macedonian kings are said to have ruled 'not by force, but by law'. Arrian wrote some five centuries later, and the speech is his composition. 26 Debated Texts

The same speech claims descent from Heracles and Aeacus for Alexander and objects to giving a living man the honours due to gods: in it, the king's standing rests on his ancestry, not on divinity. 26 Debated Texts

Cliopatria shows the empire breaking up after Alexander: from about 4.7 million km² in 323–319 BCE to about 151,000 km² in 301–292. 5 Consensus Texts

The Antigonid dynasty then ruled Macedon. Seshat-db dates it 311–168 BCE but codes no variables for it yet; Cliopatria maps 'Antigonid Macedonia' at about 138,000 km² in 277–273 BCE and 43,000 km² by 170–165. 27,5 Consensus Texts

The Antigonid king could also lead the leagues: Polybius describes Philip V addressing the Achaean council at Aegium and renewing the friendship the Achaeans had with his ancestors. 28 Consensus Texts

How power worked King · Heredity · Custom and kin · 1 unknown

How power worked

Who rules
King Consensus
How chosen
Heredity Consensus
Limits on power
Custom and kin Debated
Scale
Empire Consensus
Claim to rule
Kinship and descent Debated
Who has a say
Unknown
Why?

No source read says what, if anything, Philip's assemblies of Macedonians decided.

A relief map from the Adriatic to the Indus seen from above at an angle, with the land Cliopatria assigns to the Macedonian Empire raised as purple blocks. Step from 336 BCE, when the kingdom held Macedon and its Greek neighbours, through Alexander's conquests (332, 321) to the far smaller realm Cliopatria draws after them (310, 300). Block height follows Seshat-db's population estimate where it codes one. Territories from Cliopatria (CC BY 4.0), coastline from Natural Earth.

Macedonian Empire (Cliopatria)

Territory: Cliopatria (CC BY 4.0), simplified. Height: Seshat population, log scale; darker, fixed-height slices are not coded.

The Achaean League280 BCE – 146 BCE

A federation of cities in the northern Peloponnese that grew to take in most of the peninsula. Our main source, Polybius, was one of its statesmen.

Terms: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues: Leagues under the kings, The Achaean League

  • koina 'common [states]': the federal leagues that joined several cities into one polity 24
  • Strategus the league's elected general and chief magistrate 22
The league's men gathered in an open-air theatre above the Gulf of Corinth, grouped under the banners of their cities, each a separate polis with the same laws, weights, measures, coinage and magistrates as the rest. The elected general, the Strategus, speaks from the floor of the theatre; the assembly will confirm or refuse what is put to it. Ships lie in the gulf below and the mountains of the far shore rise beyond.

The Achaean League in assembly

Polybius dates the league's revival to the 124th Olympiad, the years Ptolemy son of Lagus, Lysimachus and Seleucus died, when Patrae and Dyme formed a league; the old league of twelve Achaean cities had been broken up by the Macedonian kings. 22 Consensus Texts

For twenty-five years the cities elected a common secretary and two generals in rotation. Then they decided to elect one general and entrust him with the direction of their affairs; the first was Margus of Caryneia. 22 Consensus Texts

Polybius says the members came to share the same laws, weights, measures and coinage, and the same magistrates, council and courts, so that the whole Peloponnese 'only falls short of being a single city' in lacking one wall. 22 Consensus Texts

In Polybius's account, the league grew by offering other cities 'equality and liberty' and making war on those who, with the kings' help, enslaved their home cities. It is the verdict of a loyal Achaean. 22 Debated Texts

Aratus of Sicyon, at twenty, freed his city from its tyrant, and the league went on to win over others, such as Mantinea, which Aratus promised security if it joined. 22 Consensus Texts

Big decisions went to the league's assembly: meeting in their regular assembly, the Achaeans unanimously confirmed a decree and proclaimed reprisals against the Aetolians. 28 Consensus Texts

Cliopatria maps the league at about 2,600 km² in 279–273 BCE and about 11,800 km² from 225 BCE until its last slice in 164–145. 5 Consensus Texts

The Achaean League ended in 146 BCE, the close of Mackil's five-century history of the koina. 24 Consensus Texts

How power worked Elected magistrates · Election · Assembly or tribune veto

How power worked

Who rules
Elected magistrates Consensus
How chosen
Election Consensus
Limits on power
Assembly or tribune veto Debated
Scale
Confederation Consensus
Claim to rule
Law Debated
Who has a say
Male citizens Debated

The Aetolian League284 BCE – 189 BCE

A federation of the mountain communities of Aetolia, north of the Gulf of Corinth, and for a time the strongest power in central Greece. Polybius, an Achaean, writes about it as an enemy.

A high mountain valley in Aetolia. Armed Aetolians crowd a meadow for the league's general assembly and raise their hands to elect the year's general; officials stand by a small temple, unable to act on matters of state until the assembly has met. On the hillside behind, raiders drive off a herd of cattle: Polybius accuses the Aetolian leaders of licensing such raids on their own allies in time of peace.

The Aetolian League elects its general

Aetolian officials could not act alone on matters of state: when Philip V asked to meet them, they replied that they could take no steps before the General Assembly of the Aetolians met. 28 Consensus Texts

The Aetolians elected their general every year; Polybius was outraged that they elected Scopas, the man most responsible for the raids on their neighbours. 28 Consensus Texts

There was competition for the office: when an Aetolian army was beaten at Medion, the townspeople mocked an Aetolian decree by inscribing the captured shields as taken from 'the present Aetolian chief magistrate and the candidates for next year's office'. 22 Consensus Texts

Polybius accuses Aetolian leaders of licensing raids in peacetime: Dorimachus, sent to guard Phigalea, let brigands drive off the cattle of the Messenians, Aetolia's own allies, and took his share of the captives. 28 Debated Texts

The league fought far from home: under an alliance, a thousand Aetolians went to Crete to help Cnossus. 28 Consensus Texts

Cliopatria maps the league from 284 BCE at about 7,500 km², growing to about 11,800 km² by 208–207; its last slice ends in 189. 5 Consensus Texts

Aitolia is one of the three best-documented koina of mainland Greece, with Boiotia and Achaia; Mackil reads its formation through shared cults and economic ties as much as war. 24 Debated Texts

How power worked Elected magistrates · Election · Assembly or tribune veto · 1 unknown

How power worked

Who rules
Elected magistrates Consensus
How chosen
Election Consensus
Limits on power
Assembly or tribune veto Debated
Scale
Confederation Consensus
Claim to rule
Law Debated
Who has a say
Unknown
Why?

Polybius mentions the Aetolians' General Assembly but not who could attend or vote in it.

Crete323 BCE – 146 BCE

The Cretan cities fought one another, made and broke alliances, and drew in outside powers. Seshat codes Hellenistic Crete from 323 BCE.

A walled hill town on Crete burning: while Lyttus's men were away on campaign, the Cnossians took the undefended town and wrecked it, as Polybius tells it. Troops with spears and shields come down from the walls, women and children are led away towards Cnossus, and smoke rises over the roofs. Offshore, a squadron of Rhodian warships that Cnossus has called in rides at anchor.

Crete: Cnossus destroys Lyttus

Polybius describes Cnossus and Gortyn subjecting all of Crete except Lyttus, then making war on Lyttus to destroy it as an example. Their allies split, and while the Lyttians were away on campaign the Cnossians took the undefended town and razed it. 28 Consensus Texts

The war split Gortyn itself: the older citizens sided with Cnossus, the younger with Lyttus. With a thousand Aetolian troops, the elders seized the citadel and exiled or killed the younger men. 28 Consensus Texts

Outside powers were drawn in: Cnossus brought in a Rhodian squadron, and Eleuthernae, suspecting the Rhodian commander of killing one of its citizens, proclaimed reprisals and went to war with Rhodes. 28 Consensus Texts

Polybius denies that Crete's constitution resembled Sparta's: Cretan laws let men acquire as much land as they could, money was held in the highest honour, and magistracies were 'annual and elected on a democratic system'. 29 Debated Texts

Seshat's largest Cretan settlement grows from about 4,000 people in the Classical period to about 24,000 in the Hellenistic, while its territory (210–240 km²) and population (5,000–30,000) figures stay the same. Seshat Consensus Texts

Across all three periods Seshat codes Crete as a 'quasi-polity' without a capital: many cities, never one state. Seshat Consensus Texts

How power worked Elected magistrates · Election · Written law · 1 unknown

How power worked

Who rules
Elected magistrates Consensus
How chosen
Election Debated
Limits on power
Written law Consensus
Scale
City-state Consensus
Claim to rule
Unknown
Why?

The sources read describe the Cretan cities' wars and magistracies, not what their rulers claimed as the basis of their authority.

Who has a say
Male citizens Debated

Artefacts

Attic white-ground lekythos: an oil flask painted with brown figures on a white ground (5th century BCE)
Attic white-ground lekythos: an oil flask painted with brown figures on a white ground (5th century BCE), 450 BCE. The Hunt Museum, Limerick (HCM 228). 30 3D model: The Hunt Museum, via Zenodo (CC BY 4.0) (source record) · CC BY 4.0
Lekythos left as a grave offering, its painted figures now worn away (4th century BCE)
Lekythos left as a grave offering, its painted figures now worn away (4th century BCE), 350 BCE. The Hunt Museum, Limerick (HCM 231). 31 3D model: The Hunt Museum, via Zenodo (CC BY 4.0) (source record) · CC BY 4.0
Kore in chiton and mantle from the Athenian Acropolis, plaster cast of the marble statue (c. 530 BCE) Cast
Kore in chiton and mantle from the Athenian Acropolis, plaster cast of the marble statue (c. 530 BCE), 530 BCE. Cast: Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection, Copenhagen (KAS1800). Original: Acropolis Museum, Athens. 32 3D scan of the cast: SMK, Public Domain Mark 1.0 (source record) · Public domain
Alexander the Great (the 'Alexander Rondanini'), plaster cast of a Roman marble copy of a work of c. 335 BCE Cast
Alexander the Great (the 'Alexander Rondanini'), plaster cast of a Roman marble copy of a work of c. 335 BCE, 335 BCE. Cast: Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection, Copenhagen (KAS538). Original: Staatliche Antikensammlungen und Glyptothek, Munich. 33 3D scan of the cast: SMK, Public Domain Mark 1.0 (source record) · Public domain
Helmeted general, the so-called Miltiades, plaster cast of a Roman marble copy of a work of 480–470 BCE Cast
Helmeted general, the so-called Miltiades, plaster cast of a Roman marble copy of a work of 480–470 BCE, 475 BCE. Cast: Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection, Copenhagen (KAS519). Original: Staatliche Antikensammlungen und Glyptothek, Munich. 34 3D scan of the cast: SMK, Public Domain Mark 1.0 (source record) · Public domain
Demosthenes standing, plaster cast of a Roman marble copy of a statue of c. 280 BCE Cast
Demosthenes standing, plaster cast of a Roman marble copy of a statue of c. 280 BCE, 280 BCE. Cast: Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection, Copenhagen (KAS629). Original: Vatican Museums (Museo Chiaramonti). 35 3D scan of the cast: SMK, Public Domain Mark 1.0 (source record) · Public domain

3D model

In numbers

  • Marks, by Seshat polity:
  • Archaic Crete
  • Classical Crete
  • Hellenistic Crete
  • Macedonian Empire
  • Background bands, by phase:
  • Archaic poleis and lawgivers
  • Democracy and its rivals
  • Leagues under the kings
Territory km², log scale
Population people, log scale
Largest settlement people, log scale
Administrative levels
Settlement hierarchy tiers
Military levels
Territory (km²)
Seshat polityYearsValue
Archaic Crete 710 BCE – 500 BCE (whole period) 167
Classical Crete 500 BCE – 323 BCE (whole period) 210–240
Macedonian Empire 359 BCE 10,000
Hellenistic Crete 323 BCE – 69 BCE (whole period) 210–240
Macedonian Empire 320 BCE 5,200,000
Macedonian Empire 300 BCE 4,400,000
Population (people)
Seshat polityYearsValue
Archaic Crete 710 BCE – 500 BCE (whole period) suspected unknown
Classical Crete 500 BCE – 323 BCE (whole period) 5,000–30,000
Macedonian Empire 359 BCE – 336 BCE 1,000,000
Hellenistic Crete 323 BCE – 69 BCE (whole period) 5,000–30,000
Macedonian Empire 321 BCE – 294 BCE 20,000,000
Largest settlement (people)
Seshat polityYearsValue
Archaic Crete 710 BCE – 500 BCE (whole period) 4,000
Classical Crete 500 BCE – 323 BCE (whole period) 4,000
Macedonian Empire 330 BCE – 312 BCE (whole period) 20,000–80,000
Hellenistic Crete 323 BCE – 69 BCE (whole period) 24,000
Administrative levels (levels)
Seshat polityYearsValue
Archaic Crete 710 BCE – 500 BCE (whole period) 5
Classical Crete 500 BCE – 323 BCE (whole period) 5
Macedonian Empire 359 BCE – 330 BCE 3
Macedonian Empire 330 BCE – 294 BCE 5
Hellenistic Crete 323 BCE – 69 BCE (whole period) 5
Settlement hierarchy (tiers)
Seshat polityYearsValue
Archaic Crete 710 BCE – 500 BCE (whole period) 1–5
Classical Crete 500 BCE – 323 BCE (whole period) 1–5
Macedonian Empire 330 BCE – 312 BCE (whole period) 5
Hellenistic Crete 323 BCE – 69 BCE (whole period) 1–5
Military levels (levels)
Seshat polityYearsValue
Archaic Crete 710 BCE – 500 BCE (whole period) 5
Classical Crete 500 BCE – 323 BCE (whole period) 5
Macedonian Empire 330 BCE – 312 BCE (whole period) 5–8
Hellenistic Crete 323 BCE – 69 BCE (whole period) 5

Values as Seshat codes them: bands are ranges, dots single values, flat bars values given for a whole period, hatching “unknown”; from one Seshat polity to the next, marks alternate between a light tone and a darker one with dashed joining lines (the key above names each polity). Source: Seshat Global History Databank (Equinox-2020), CC BY 4.0; and the Seshat Databank, seshat-db.com (no licence stated; attribution).

Governance fingerprint

Seshat's institutional variables, phase by phase. Hover or focus a cell for the values and years.

Archaic poleis and lawgiversDemocracy and its rivalsLeagues under the kings
Seshat variable CreteCreteMacedonCrete
Rulers are gods Rulers are gods, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Inferred absent. Archaic Crete: inferred absent. Rulers are gods, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Rulers are gods, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Rulers are gods, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Rulers legitimated by gods Rulers legitimated by gods, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Inferred absent. Archaic Crete: inferred absent. Rulers legitimated by gods, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Rulers legitimated by gods, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Rulers legitimated by gods, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Executive checked by government Executive checked by government, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Executive checked by government, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Executive checked by government, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Executive checked by government, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Executive checked from outside Executive checked from outside, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Executive checked from outside, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Executive checked from outside, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Executive checked from outside, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Impeachment Impeachment, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Impeachment, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Impeachment, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Impeachment, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Elite status hereditary Elite status hereditary, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Inferred absent. Archaic Crete: inferred absent. Elite status hereditary, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Inferred absent. Classical Crete: inferred absent. Elite status hereditary, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Elite status hereditary, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Formal legal code Formal legal code, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Present. Archaic Crete: present. Formal legal code, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Present. Classical Crete: present. Formal legal code, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Formal legal code, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Present. Hellenistic Crete: present.
Courts Courts, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Present. Archaic Crete: present. Courts, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Present. Classical Crete: present. Courts, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Courts, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Present. Hellenistic Crete: present.
Judges Judges, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Present. Archaic Crete: present. Judges, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Present. Classical Crete: present. Judges, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Judges, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Present. Hellenistic Crete: present.
Professional lawyers Professional lawyers, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Absent. Archaic Crete: absent. Professional lawyers, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Absent. Classical Crete: absent. Professional lawyers, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Absent. Macedonian Empire: absent. Professional lawyers, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Absent. Hellenistic Crete: absent.
Full-time bureaucrats Full-time bureaucrats, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Present. Archaic Crete: present. Full-time bureaucrats, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Present. Classical Crete: present. Full-time bureaucrats, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Full-time bureaucrats, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Present. Hellenistic Crete: present.
Examination system Examination system, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Examination system, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Examination system, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Absent. Macedonian Empire: absent. Examination system, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Merit promotion Merit promotion, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Merit promotion, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat. Merit promotion, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Absent. Macedonian Empire: absent. Merit promotion, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Unknown. no value in Seshat.
Government buildings Government buildings, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: Present. Archaic Crete: present. Government buildings, Democracy and its rivals: Crete: Present. Classical Crete: present. Government buildings, Leagues under the kings: Macedon: Present. Macedonian Empire: present. Government buildings, Leagues under the kings: Crete: Present. Hellenistic Crete: present.
  • Present
  • Inferred present
  • Absent
  • Inferred absent
  • Unknown
  • Not coded in Seshat
  • Mixed: present in one Seshat polity or period, absent in another

Not coded in Seshat: Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Athens, Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Sparta, Democracy and its rivals: Athens, Democracy and its rivals: Sparta, Democracy and its rivals: Democracies beyond Athens, Leagues under the kings: The Achaean League, Leagues under the kings: The Aetolian League. The Seshat Databank has no polity for them, so their six axes rest on the cited scholarship alone.

The axes against Seshat

6 agree, 0 disagree.

Show the 6 pairs that agree
  • Agree Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: who rules coded “Elected magistrates”, which implies rulers are gods absent; Seshat has it inferred absent.
  • Agree Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: limits on power coded “Written law”, which implies formal legal code present; Seshat has it present.
  • Agree Archaic poleis and lawgivers: Crete: claim to rule coded “Law”, which implies formal legal code present; Seshat has it present.
  • Agree Democracy and its rivals: Crete: limits on power coded “Written law”, which implies formal legal code present; Seshat has it present.
  • Agree Democracy and its rivals: Crete: claim to rule coded “Law”, which implies formal legal code present; Seshat has it present.
  • Agree Leagues under the kings: Crete: limits on power coded “Written law”, which implies formal legal code present; Seshat has it present.

Only pairs where an axis value on its own implies a Seshat variable are compared; the rest is not counted as disagreement. 3 more pairs have no Seshat value.

Source: Seshat Global History Databank (Equinox-2020), CC BY 4.0; Seshat Databank, seshat-db.com (no licence stated; attribution).

Compare

Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues Rome: The kings Achaemenid Persia: Cyrus and Cambyses India: After the cities: the Vedic age ? = unknown or not coded
Comparison: Greece: Athens, Sparta and the leagues, Rome: The kings, Achaemenid Persia: Cyrus and Cambyses, India: After the cities: the Vedic age
AxisGreece: Athens, Sparta and the leaguesRome: The kingsAchaemenid Persia: Cyrus and CambysesIndia: After the cities: the Vedic age
Who rulesElected magistratesKingEmperorChief
How chosenMixedMixedConquest or coupMixed
Limits on powerWritten lawCouncilCustom and kinCouncil
ScaleCity-stateCity-stateEmpireConfederation
Claim to ruleLawDivine mandateDivine mandateDivine mandate
Who has a sayProperty ownersUnknownA narrow eliteA narrow elite

Legacy

The word itself is Greek. In the funeral speech Thucydides gives Pericles, Athens's government 'favors the many instead of the few; this is why it is called a democracy' (δημοκρατία). 10,13 Consensus Texts

Historians still treat Athens as the first western democracy and still argue about how it worked: Josiah Ober asks why it worked as well and for as long as it did. 17 Consensus Texts

Greek cities wrote their laws up in public for many to read, but made little use of writing in court; Gagarin argues that this kept Greek law from becoming technical and that no legal profession developed. 2 Debated Texts

Macedon's victory did not end the cities: Ober stresses that Greek cities stayed populous and wealthy after Alexander, and that their economy and culture passed to the Romans. 11 Debated Texts

See also forms of government.

Sources

Bibliography

35 sources, numbered as cited: 1 paper · 10 books · 2 datasets · 22 primary sources

  1. Primary Aristotle (attributed) (trans. H. Rackham) (330 BCE). The Athenian Constitution (Athenaion Politeia). Perseus Digital Library. Written in the 320s BCE, two to three centuries after the archaic reforms it describes. Chapters 3-8, 12, 14, 21-22, 24, 26-27, 41-44, 62-65 read.
  2. Book Gagarin, M. (2008). Writing Greek Law. Cambridge University Press (open access).
  3. Primary Plutarch (trans. B. Perrin) (100). Life of Lycurgus. Loeb Classical Library / LacusCurtius. Written about eight centuries after the events it describes. Chapters 5-8, 10-13 and 26 read.
  4. Book Forsdyke, S. (2009). Exile, Ostracism, and Democracy: The Politics of Expulsion in Ancient Greece. Princeton University Press (first published 2005).
  5. Dataset Bennett, J. S., Mutch, E., Tollefson, A., et al. (2025). Cliopatria - A geospatial database of world-wide political entities from 3400BCE to 2024CE. Scientific Data 12. Cliopatria: open geospatial dataset of over 1600 political entities, 3400 BCE–2024 CE.
  6. Primary Aristotle (ed. W. D. Ross) (330 BCE). Politics (Greek text). Perseus Digital Library. Source of the Greek forms ἔφοροι, κόσμοι, γέροντες, φιδίτια and ἀνδρεῖα (1272a).
  7. Primary Herodotus (trans. A. D. Godley) (430 BCE). The Histories. Perseus Digital Library. 5.78 and 6.56-57 read.
  8. Book Hodkinson, S. (2009). Property and Wealth in Classical Sparta. The Classical Press of Wales (first published 2000).
  9. Primary Aristotle (trans. H. Rackham) (330 BCE). Politics. Perseus Digital Library. Book 2, 1270a-1272b (Sparta and Crete) read.
  10. Primary Thucydides (trans. R. Crawley) (400 BCE). The History of the Peloponnesian War. Perseus Digital Library. 1.87, 2.37, 2.65 and 7.55 read.
  11. Book Ober, J. (2015). The Rise and Fall of Classical Greece. Princeton University Press.
  12. Primary Diodorus Siculus (trans. C. B. Welles) (30 BCE). The Library of History, Book XVI, 66-95. Loeb Classical Library vol. VIII (1963) / LacusCurtius. 16.85-89 (Chaeronea and the congress at Corinth) read.
  13. Primary Thucydides (ed. H. S. Jones, J. E. Powell) (400 BCE). Historiae (Greek text). Perseus Digital Library. Source of the Greek forms δημοκρατία (2.37) and βοῇ (1.87).
  14. Primary Aristotle (attributed) (ed. F. G. Kenyon) (330 BCE). Athenaion Politeia (Greek text). Perseus Digital Library. Source of the Greek forms βουλή (43.2), κληρωτήρια and πινάκια (63.2) and κανονίδες (64.2).
  15. Book Lang, M., rev. Camp, J. McK. (2004). The Athenian Citizen: Democracy in the Athenian Agora (Agora Picture Book 4, 2nd ed.). American School of Classical Studies at Athens. Read in full (the ASCSA PDF): the Pnyx and Agora, the Council, ostracism, the law against tyranny and the jurors' allotment machines (pp. 5-26).
  16. Primary Plutarch (trans. B. Perrin) (100). Life of Aristides. Loeb Classical Library / LacusCurtius. Chapter 7 (the ostracism procedure) read.
  17. Book Ober, J. (1989). Mass and Elite in Democratic Athens: Rhetoric, Ideology, and the Power of the People. Princeton University Press.
  18. Book Pritchard, D. M. (2015). Public Spending and Democracy in Classical Athens. University of Texas Press.
  19. Book Robinson, E. W. (2011). Democracy beyond Athens: Popular Government in the Greek Classical Age. Cambridge University Press.
  20. Primary Diodorus Siculus (trans. C. H. Oldfather) (30 BCE). The Library of History, Book XI. Loeb Classical Library vol. IV (1946) / LacusCurtius. 11.86-87 (petalism at Syracuse) read.
  21. Book Teegarden, D. A. (2014). Death to Tyrants!: Ancient Greek Democracy and the Struggle against Tyranny. Princeton University Press.
  22. Primary Polybius (trans. W. R. Paton) (150 BCE). The Histories, Book II. Loeb Classical Library / LacusCurtius. Polybius was an Achaean statesman before his deportation to Rome. 2.4 and 2.37-43 read.
  23. Paper Fleck, R. K., Hanssen, F. A. (2006). The Origins of Democracy: A Model with Application to Ancient Greece. The Journal of Law and Economics 49.
  24. Book Mackil, E. (2013). Creating a Common Polity: Religion, Economy, and Politics in the Making of the Greek Koinon. University of California Press.
  25. Primary Diodorus Siculus (trans. C. L. Sherman) (30 BCE). The Library of History, Book XVI, 1-20. Loeb Classical Library vol. VII (1952) / LacusCurtius. 16.1-4 (Philip's accession, his assemblies and the phalanx) read.
  26. Primary Arrian (trans. E. J. Chinnock) (150). The Anabasis of Alexander, Book IV. Wikisource. 4.11, the speech Arrian gives Callisthenes against prostration, read.
  27. Dataset Seshat: Global History Databank (2026). Seshat Databank API (seshat-db.com), social-complexity and general variables. Snapshot of the API responses taken 15 Nov 2026; the site states no licence. Used where Equinox-2020 has no polity for a page's period.
  28. Primary Polybius (trans. W. R. Paton) (150 BCE). The Histories, Book IV. Loeb Classical Library / LacusCurtius. 4.3-4, 4.26-27 and 4.53-54 read.
  29. Primary Polybius (trans. W. R. Paton) (150 BCE). The Histories, Book VI. Loeb Classical Library / LacusCurtius.
  30. Primary The Hunt Museum, Limerick (2026). Attic white-ground lekythos (HCM 228), 3D model. Zenodo, doi:10.5281/zenodo.18949666 (CC BY 4.0).
  31. Primary The Hunt Museum, Limerick (2026). Vase or lekythos (HCM 231), 3D model. Zenodo, doi:10.5281/zenodo.18946547 (CC BY 4.0).
  32. Primary Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection (2020). Kore in chiton and mantle (plaster cast KAS1800). SMK Open.
  33. Primary Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection (2020). Alexander the Great, standing, 'Alexander Rondanini' (plaster cast KAS538). SMK Open.
  34. Primary Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection (2020). Helmeted warrior, 'Miltiades' (plaster cast KAS519). SMK Open.
  35. Primary Statens Museum for Kunst, Royal Cast Collection (2020). Portrait of Demosthenes, standing (plaster cast KAS629). SMK Open.

Quantitative values from the Seshat Global History Databank (Equinox-2020), licensed CC BY 4.0. Dataset: Seshat Equinox Packaged Data (v.1). See also Seshat: The Global History Databank (Turchin et al. 2015).

Values for polities Equinox-2020 does not cover come from the Seshat Databank at seshat-db.com (Seshat: Global History Databank), snapshotted from its API on 2026-11-16. No licence is stated on seshat-db.com; used with attribution. Snapshot: Seshat Databank API (seshat-db.com), social-complexity and general variables.